Dots vs Muse vs Grok Bot: Which Always-On AI Agent to Pay For

By Beau Johnson··9 min read

Quick answer

OpenAI Dots, Meta Muse and xAI Grok Bot are all always-on AI agents. In an 8-job test they scored within two points of each other. Go with Dots if you already pay for ChatGPT Pro or work in Slack or Teams, Muse if you're in the US and want to start free, and Grok Bot if you want a team of bots or already pay for Cursor.

OpenAI, Meta and xAI each shipped an always-on AI agent within about seven weeks of each other: Dots, Muse and Grok Bot. In this video I explain how each one works, what it costs, how all three did when one tester gave them the same week of chores, and which one I'd actually pay for. It's for anyone who wants an agent to handle real tasks like bills, forms and email but isn't sure which one to trust with them.

What I cover in this video

  • 0:00: Three AI companies shipped the same kind of product, and OpenAI's launch demo stalled on stage
  • 0:46: What an always-on AI agent is and how it's different from a chatbot
  • 1:33: OpenAI Dots, its custom rules and its pricing
  • 2:19: Meta Muse, WhatsApp, the Sentinel safety agent and the free tier
  • 3:05: xAI Grok Bot and its team of bots
  • 4:38: The head-to-head test: same week, same chores
  • 6:10: Speed vs asking permission, plus the settings to change first
  • 7:44: Which AI agent to pick

What an always-on AI agent actually is

A chatbot answers you, and that's all it does. An always-on agent gets its own real computer in the cloud, with a browser, your apps, your files and a memory of who you are. You send it one sentence, like "Find me a cheaper phone plan." It opens the websites, fills out the forms, reads your inbox and gets all the way to checkout. It's supposed to come back to you only when it needs a yes, like "pay this" or "send this." Then it keeps going, even while your laptop is closed.

All three of these work that way. Where they differ is where they live, what they cost and how careful they are. If you're new to agents in general, my AI Agents page is a good place to start.

The three agents compared

OpenAI Dots: the careful one

OpenAI launched Dots on September 29th at DevDay, and it runs on their new model, GPT-6 Astra. Every Dot gets its own cloud computer, and you talk to it where you already work: ChatGPT, Slack, Teams or even a voice call. It connects to more than 4,000 apps.

The part I like most is custom rules. You choose how much freedom it gets, from four levels:

  • Just do it
  • Do it if I already approved it
  • Ask me first
  • Hand it back to me

Anything that touches your accounts also gets an extra review. The catch is price: your first Dot comes with ChatGPT Pro, which starts at $100 a month. On Pro, Dots isn't available yet in Europe, the UK or Switzerland.

Meta Muse: the one your parents could use

Meta launched Muse on September 8th. You can use it in the Muse app, on the web, or just by texting it in WhatsApp. Meta's own examples are everyday tasks: sell your car for more, lower a bill, or turn an Instagram recipe reel into a grocery list.

Its safety setup is smart. Muse runs on its own locked-down cloud computer, and a second agent on that computer, called Sentinel, has to approve every trip Muse makes to the internet. It's basically a bouncer. When Muse buys something, it pays with a one-time card through Stripe's Link instead of your real card, and you can watch its browser the whole time.

Muse is free to start with a weekly limit. The paid tiers are $20 for Power and $100 for Maximum. Right now it runs on Muse Spark, and Meta's new Muse Wonder model is coming to it soon. It's launching in the US first.

xAI Grok Bot: a staff, not an assistant

Grok Bot actually came out first, in beta on August 11th. xAI built it together with Cursor. You don't get one assistant, you get a team: a chief-of-staff bot at the top that manages specialist bots, and the bots message each other.

You can teach it by doing a job once while it watches. It saves that as a skill and reruns it on a schedule. As of October 9th it also has its own email address, and you can tag it on X to start a job.

One thing to be careful about: every bot shares one computer, which means the same files, the same browser and the same logins. Anything you give one bot, they can all see. It costs about $30 a month for new users on X's subscription, or it's included if you already pay $20 for Cursor Pro.

The head-to-head test: same week, same chores

A channel called Hyperautomation Labs ran the test I wanted to see. It used one made-up family and eight jobs, with the same prompts and 20 minutes per job. Nothing was actually paid, sent or submitted.

  • Monday, wasted subscriptions: All three found the same $779.76 a year. Grok Bot did it in about a minute, Dots took seven and Muse took nine.
  • Tuesday, a Delta form: Dots and Muse stopped at submit, which is what they should do. Grok Bot got stuck on the airport picker and scheduled its own retry.
  • Wednesday, haggling with AT&T's sales chat as a new customer: Same company, three different prices: about 56 for Grok Bot, 58 for Dots and about 61 for Muse.
  • Thursday, 167 emails: All three found the five that mattered and all three caught the scam. Muse wrote the best summary, but with the default Gmail access it couldn't archive anything.
  • Friday, a school newsletter: Grok Bot and Muse got it right. Dots added a fourth-grade event by mistake.
  • Saturday, a 35-field insurance claim: All three were perfect.
  • Sunday, reporting a pothole to the city: Grok Bot had it ready to file in 4 minutes, but it uploaded the photo without asking. Dots and Muse both asked first.

Final score: Grok Bot 44.5, Dots 43.5, Muse 42.5. The free one finished one point behind the $100 one. Keep in mind this was one tester using his own scoring.

Speed vs asking permission, and the settings to change first

Here's the pattern. Grok Bot is the fastest, taking about a minute on most jobs, and it keeps going on its own. But the app froze twice on the tester's Mac, and it uploaded that photo without asking. Dots was the steadiest, but it costs $100 and it's slow on websites. Muse gave the clearest answers and asks before it acts, but it's slow to get going. The real choice is speed vs asking permission.

Before any of these touch your inbox, these are the switches the tester recommends:

  • Muse: Turn off "help improve our AI models" and set permissions to always ask.
  • Dots: Make a custom rule so money and messages ask you first, and turn off "improve the model for everyone."
  • Grok Bot: Set your computer to ask every time, keep email drafts on and set a spending cap.
  • All of them: Never paste a password into the chat.

Here's how I'd use one. In my resale business, our shipment updates are spread across WhatsApp, the forwarder's website and UPS emails, and I check all three by hand. What I want is one agent that checks all three every morning and gives me one list. I'm going to try Grok Bot first because it's already on my Mac. I'll teach it the forwarder site once and forward the UPS emails to its own inbox. That's the job I'd actually pay for.

Key takeaways

  • Pick Dots if you already pay for ChatGPT Pro or your team lives in Slack or Teams. It has the most detailed permission rules.
  • Pick Muse if you're in the US and want to start free. It works inside WhatsApp, and Sentinel approves every trip to the internet.
  • Pick Grok Bot if you want a whole team of bots or you already pay for Cursor. Just remember every bot shares one computer.
  • In the 8-job test the three finished within two points of each other, so no one clearly won. The best one is the one you'll actually use.
  • Change the privacy and permission settings before you connect any of them to your email or money.

FAQ

How much do Dots, Muse and Grok Bot cost?

Your first Dot comes with ChatGPT Pro, which starts at $100 a month. Muse is free to start with a weekly limit, with $20 Power and $100 Maximum tiers. Grok Bot is about $30 a month for new users on X's subscription, or included if you already pay $20 for Cursor Pro.

Which AI agent won the head-to-head test?

In Hyperautomation Labs' 8-job test, Grok Bot scored 44.5, Dots 43.5 and Muse 42.5. That's one tester using his own scoring, and the gap is small enough that there's no clear winner.

What is Sentinel in Meta Muse?

Sentinel is a second agent that runs on the same locked-down cloud computer as Muse. It has to approve every trip Muse makes to the internet, like a bouncer.

Is Grok Bot safe to give my accounts to?

Be careful. Every Grok Bot bot shares one computer with the same files, browser and logins, so anything you give one bot, they can all see. The tester recommends setting it to ask every time, keeping email drafts on, setting a spending cap and never pasting a password into the chat.

Chapters

  1. 0:00Three AI companies, one product
  2. 0:46What an always-on AI agent is
  3. 1:30OpenAI Dots: custom rules and pricing
  4. 2:24Meta Muse: WhatsApp, Sentinel and the free tier
  5. 3:32xAI Grok Bot: a whole team of bots
  6. 4:32Same week, same chores: the head-to-head test
  7. 6:17Speed vs asking permission
  8. 6:46Settings to flip before you start
  9. 7:13How I'd use an AI agent in my business
  10. 7:41Which AI agent to pick
  11. 8:02Which one are y ou trying first?

Transcript

Read the full transcript

0:00Three of the biggest AI companies just shipped the exact same product. OpenAI has Dots, Meta has Muse, and XAI has Grockbot. All three in about 7 weeks, and none of them are chat bots. You give them a job, they go off and do it on their own computer in the cloud, and they keep working while your laptop is closed. And OpenAI's big launch demo stalled right there on stage. Two days later, they posted a rerun and the caption said, "Dots demo. Now with better Wi-Fi." Come on now. So, in this video, we're going to be breaking down how these agents actually work, what each one is good at, how they did when someone gave all three the exact same week of chores, and which one I'd actually pay for. Let's jump right into

0:46it. So, what is an always on agent exactly? A chatbot answers you. That's it. An always on agent gets its own computer, a real one running in the cloud with a browser, your apps, your files, and a memory of who you are. So, you send it one sentence, "Find me a cheaper phone plan." And then it opens the websites, fills out the forms, reads your inbox, and gets all the way to checkout. And here's the important part. It's supposed to only come back to you when it needs a yes. Pay this, send this, you say yes, and it keeps going. So all three work like this. The difference is where they live, what they cost, and how careful they are. And like I said, careful is going to come up again. So let's start with dots. OpenAI

1:33launched it on September 29th at Devday, and it runs on their new model, GPT6 Astra. Every DOT gets its own cloud computer, and you talk to it right where you already work. Chat, GPT, Slack, Teams, even a voice call. And it plugs into over 4,000 apps. And here's the part I actually like. Custom rules. You decide how much freedom it gets on four levels. Just do it. Do it if I already approved it. Ask me first, or hand it back to me. And anything that touches your accounts gets an extra review. Now, the catch. Your first DOT comes with ChatGpt Pro. And Pro starts at $100 a month. And on Pro, Dots isn't available yet in Europe. the UK or Switzerland.

2:19So, DOTS is the careful one and it lives where a lot of you already work. Next up, Muse. Meta launched it on September 8th and their pitch is pretty simple. It doesn't just answer questions. It actually does the work. You can use it in the Muse app on the web or just text it inside of WhatsApp. And Meta's own examples are normal people stuff. Sell your car for more. Lower a bill. turn an Instagram recipe reel into a grocery list. So, how does it keep itself in check? This part is actually pretty clever. Muse runs on its own locked down computer in the cloud. And there's a second agent on that computer called Sentinel. Every time Muse wants to go out to the internet, Sentinel has to say, "Okay." It's basically a bouncer.

3:05And when it buys something, it pays with a one-time card through Stripe's link instead of your real card. And you can watch its browser the whole time. The price free to start with a weekly limit. $20 for power 100 for maximum. Right now it runs on Muse Spark and Meta's new Muse Wonder model is coming to it soon. It's US first. So Muse is the one your parents could actually use. It's free to start and it's in WhatsApp. And then there's Grockbot. This one actually came out first in beta on August 11th from XAI built together with Cursor. And Grockbot is different. You don't get an assistant. You get a team. So, there's a chief of staff bot at the top and it manages a bunch of specialist bots under

3:52it and they actually message each other. And then you can teach them. You do the job once while it watches. It saves that as a skill and it reruns it on a schedule. It even has its own email address. Now, that rolled out October 9th and you can tag it on X to start a job. But here's something to be wary about. Every bot shares one computer. Same files, same browser, same login. So, anything you give one bot, they can all see. Scary price. It's about $30 a month for new users on X's subscription or it's included if you already pay 20 for Cursor Pro. So, Grockbot isn't an assistant, it's a staff. So, how do they actually do with real chores? A channel called Hyper Automation Labs ran the

4:38exact test I wanted to see. One madeup family, eight jobs, same prompts, 20 minutes a job, and nothing actually paid, sent, or submitted. Monday, find the wasted subscriptions. All three found the exact same $779.76 a year, but Grockbot did it in about a minute. Dots took seven, Muse took nine. Tuesday, a delta form. Dots and Muse stopped right at submit like they should. Grockbot got stuck on the airport picker, so it scheduled its own retry, which is kind of impressive and kind of annoying. Wednesday, Haggle with AT&T's sales chat as a new customer. Same company, three different prices. Grock got about 56, Dots 58, Muse about

5:2461. Thursday, 167 emails. All three found all five that mattered and they all caught the scam. Muse wrote the best summary, but with the default Gmail access, it couldn't archive anything. Friday, a school newsletter. Grock and Muse nailed it. Dots added a fourth grade event by mistake. Saturday, a 35 field insurance claim. All three perfect. Sunday, report a pothole to the city. Grockbot had it ready to file in 4 minutes, which is insane, but it uploaded the photo without asking. Dots and Muse both asked first. And the final score, Grockbot 44 and a half, Dots 43 and a half, Muse 42 and a half. So, the free one finished one point behind the

6:10$100 one. Absolutely insane. Now, this is one tester with his own scoring. So, take that for what you will. So, here's the real pattern. Grockbot is the fastest, about a minute on most jobs, and it keeps going on its own. But the app froze twice on the tester's Mac and it uploaded that photo without asking. Dots was the steadiest, but it's $100 and it's slow on websites. Muse gave the clearest answers and it asks before it acts, but it's slow to get going. Speed versus asking permission. That's the real choice. So, before any of these touch your inbox, here are the switches that tester recommends. Muse. Turn off help improve our AI models and set permissions to always ask. Dots. Make a

6:58custom rule so money and messages ask you first and turn off improve the model for everyone. Grockbot. Set your computer to ask every time. Keep email drafts on and set a spending cap. And never paste a password into the chat. So, here's how I'd actually use one of these. In my resale business, our shipments are scattered across WhatsApp, the forwarder's website, and UPS emails, and I'm checking all three by hand. So, the dream is one agent that checks all three every morning and hands me one list. I'm going to try Grockbot first because it's already on my Mac. Teach at the forwarder site once, and forward the UPS emails to its own inbox. That's the job I'd actually pay for. So, who should pick which? If you already pay for chat

7:44GPT Pro or your team lives in Slack or Teams, go Dots. If you're in the US and you want to start free, go Muse. And if you want a whole team of bots or you already pay for Cursor, go Grockbot. There's no knockout here. The best one is the one you'll actually use. Comment down below which one are you trying first. I want to know. And if you want to learn how to build with all of this, we have a free community called Shipping School. We do boot camp calls every week and we keep everybody up to date on all the latest drops. The link is down below along with our free Discord. We'll see you in the next one. Have a blessed day.

Ready to start building with AI?

Join the Shipping Skool community free. Paid members get live bootcamp calls every week and weekly-updated courses.

Join Shipping Skool

Keep reading